During a weeklong assembly that ended Saturday, August 11, 2007 the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) again loosened its standards on homosexuality. While they voted down a measure that would have ended the church's celibacy requirement for homosexual clergy, they voted in favor of refraining from disciplining homosexual clergy who are in committed relationships.
These types of rulings always confuse me because I can never see the logic. By keeping the celibacy requirement they are acknowledging that homosexual sex is a sin. At the same time, by refraining from discipline they are effectivley endorsing the sin.
If I were in a 'committed' adulterous affair, I would not expect my church to say, as long as I am cheating on my wife with only one woman, they will not do anything about it. I expect my church to uphold Biblical truths and call me on the carpet for my sinful actions. If I repent of my sin, I can be restored within the body. If I continue to sin, I expect my church to remove me from any leadership position.
You would not ignore cancer in your body. You would take action to remove it before it spreads and destroys your body. The same implications are true with allowing sin to stay within the church body, specifically the leadership.
That being said, every one of us who walks through a church door is a sinner and fall short of the glory of God. Homosexuality is no worse of a short falling that stealing a pack of gum.
For those who have accepted Jesus as Lord and Savior, we are forgiven sinners. As forgiven sinners we still struggle to stay away from our sinful nature, but as forgiven sinners we acknowledge our sin and turn from it.
The action of the ELCA strikes me as a compromise between those who believe the Bible and those who do not. You can never compromise the Bible. For those Lutherans who are concerned about a split, do not be. Separating yourself from satanic influences is the best thing you could do.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
Here is an interesting follow up for you Randy. The Dallas Morning News reported on Saturday 8/11/2007 that a controversy was boiling over at High Point Church. I suggest we all read that article but the long and the short of it is this. The church standing on principle rescinded its offer to conduct a funeral memorial service for a family member of one their staff when it was found out that the family (minus the staff member) was planning on celebrating the deceased homosexual lifestyle. This included some questionable photos of the loved one. The church, after it rescinded the use of its building offered to pay for the rent on another facility and it even provided food for the 100 plus mourners following the memorial service.
I applaud the church for taking a principled stand, they expressed the love of Christ during the entire time.
Here is the link to read the article: http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/latestnews/stories/081007dnmetgayfuneral.3617689.html
You are not being very inclusive. Just kidding.
I had read the article after I did the post. The article also discussed the church praying for the member’s brother while he was sick and ministering to him while in the hospital. Unfortunately this Christian love will be overshadowed because the church will not endorse sinful activity.
I really dislike the cliché ‘love the sinner, hate the sin’, but this is a visible example of that. You cannot directly or indirectly support sinful activity. That should never stop you from showing Christ’s love to an individual who is participating in un-Godly activity. I applaud the manner in which this church handled the situation.
I would like to add a footnote next the title Lutherans. There does exist a bifurcation within the Lutheran denomination. The more conservative wing, and the one that more closely follows the theology of Luther, is the Missouri Synod affiliated congregations. Most of who would consider the ELCA movement basically parallel to a liberal sided Baptist or Pentecostal denomination. This latest development would not be surprising as ELCA is considered easily compromised since they are more concerned with church growth and Spirit filledness than the Gospel. As you might have realized I align myself more closely with the Missouri Synod side and consider ELCA Christians, but not Lutherans.
That’s not to say that more conservative denominations are immune to the corruption of sin, just review your previous post on the Episcopal Church. Look how sin can wrangle in and out of the tiniest crevasses. This is just another signpost to be thankful for strong leaders and to pray for those who are not.
I happened to catch the story on the gay funeral and must say I am not so quick to shower accolades upon this church. Do they plan to suspend future funerals if they discover the deceased was an alcoholic? What about a fornicator, drug addict, blasphemer, (e.g. tongues speaker who was mistaken) or simply an angry old man. I think what we have here is a selective form of piety by this congregation. Consistency in the end might posit them all in the domain of hypocrisy.
Should the Dallas church suspend future funerals for others? If the funeral is going to celebrate the deceased’s alcoholism or celebrate their adultery or drug addiction, then absolutely yes. It was the planned celebration of the deceased’s homosexuality that caused the cancellation.
There is nothing hypocritical about a church not allowing their facility to be used to endorse un-Godly activities. It should be the norm.
The difference here is I am making a distinction between the deceased and someone who is an active participant in the congregation. Now, as far as the congregation is concerned, I am in total agreement. I was the first to criticize the leadership at saddleback church for their lack of expediency in acting on knowledge concerning the Murdoch situation. Just like any member, a time frame is given to repent and if it is not, excommunication. Simple, Biblical. However, if he should die would I refuse his funeral? No. The man is dead. God is his judge now. Am I celebrating and approving his lifestyle? Absolutely not.
I don’t think you can say the church would be using its facilities to promote un-Godly activities. If that we so, they would have to deny an obese person a funeral lest they be endorsing and celebrating a lifestyle of un–Godly gluttony.
Pat Robertson said God told him George Bush would win the election in a landslide. Being only a 51% margin, Mr. Robertson should be denied a funeral for it would place the church in the compromising position of condoning blaspheme.
When the church buried Mother Teresa, we they endorsing her un-Godly activities?
On the surface the actions of this church do seem pietistic, upon further reflection however, they appear to lack all prudence.
According to the article the funeral was cancelled because it WAS going to be a celebration of the gay lifestyle. There was a photo montage which included homosexual pictures and “the family asked to have its own people officiate the service”. This precluded any control by the church of the message to be presented.
I am not saying a church should not conduct a funeral service for an unrepentant person. This is a great opportunity for the Gospel message to reach people who might otherwise never show up in a church or talk to ‘one of those Christians’. We all have human frailties that should be repented of and not celebrated.
A church building is not a government rec center, open to the public for whatever they want to do. It is a tool to be used for spreading the Gospel of Jesus Christ. I would never allow it to be used for a non-Christian religious service, including some mamby pamby ‘ecumenical’ community event. I would never allow it to be used for a meeting of atheists (unless it was for a ‘Does God Exist’ debate with a panel of Christians). I would not allow it to be used for a wife swapping party. So why would I allow it to be used for a celebration of sinful activity.
I found the article about turning down the funeral very interesting. I think the church should have turned down the funeral. Not because the man was gay but because homosexuality itself was going to be celebrated. As a person whom has performed funerals, the funeral is not for the person who has died, they are gone. A funeral is for the people who are still alive. The church must speak the truth of the Bible always and that truth will offend people. The church cannot turn a blind eye to the people who are still alive and ignore the impending judgment they will face someday. To allow homosexuality to be celebrated would be slapping Jesus in the face in his own house. Many people and churches for that matter tip toe around the issue of homosexuality because of political correctness and fear of being labeled a bigot. But if a white power person wanted to hold a funeral for one of there members in an African American church and during the funeral indorse white supremacy I don’t think we would be having this discussion. Of course any Bible based church should turn down the funeral that wants to celebrate homosexuality.
Now I must put some of the blame on this church. They did not do their homework and find out the proper information before hand. All churches need to put in writing a policy regarding funerals in advance. Maybe this whole story will get churches to wake up and see that homosexuality is here to stay and each church better decide now what they are going to do before they are faced with the exact same problem.
My question is why would a family expect a church to allow homosexuality in a church that has taken a stand against homosexuality? Might this whole problem have an agenda?
Post a Comment