I just found out I am in trouble. Pope Benedict XVI approved a document saying non-Catholic Christian communities are either defective or not true churches, and the Roman Catholic Church provides the only true path to salvation. I am pretty sure that in John 14:6 Jesus said "I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.” And in Acts 2:21 Peter tells us “everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved.” I see nothing about the Catholic Church, the Pope or any priest being part of my salvation.
The argument that other churches do not have ‘apostolic succession’, making them inferior, also has me scratching my head. Paul went to the gentiles to spread the Gospel of Jesus Christ. None of those believers would have had any ‘apostolic succession’ since Paul was not one of the twelve. In fact, Jews for Jesus would have a better claim of ‘apostolic succession’ than the Catholic Church, since the apostles mainly taught Jews.
The Pope did get one thing right when the report stated "Christ 'established here on earth' only one church". That Church was called the Way in Acts. That Church consists of anyone who believes that Jesus was God in the flesh, he lived a sinless life, was crucified for everyone’s sin and rose from the dead overcoming death, that Jesus is the ONLY way to salvation, that salvation is a gift from God and cannot be earned, and that the Bible is the inerrant Word of God.
If you believe what was just stated, I do not care what denomination you are. Anything other than that is manmade and that is when the problems begin. Diverting from scripture is when Satan gets a foothold.
I was glad to see the Pope does not see me as a total loser. In referencing non-Catholic Churches the document stated "In fact the Spirit of Christ has not refrained from using them as instruments of salvation, whose value derives from that fullness of grace and of truth which has been entrusted to the Catholic Church." Looks like I dodge a bullet and can go back to reading the Bible instead of going to the confessional.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
I would like to offer a footnote to the third paragraph or "Creed" portion of the post. Although I agree completely with the greater portion of the requirements, it's the last sentence that compels me to write this post. Biblical inerrancy is strictly a modern construct and including it as an absolute introduces some problems. As a necessity, this would exclude Christians for the better part of the first four centuries after Christ when no complete Bible, as we know it, yet existed. Furthermore the term is highly subjective, being easily muddled in the language of modernity. We tend to think of first century Christians as a unified monolith with the apostles leaving Pentecost with their red letter editions in hand ready to preach the word. The fact that we have the Apostles Creed goes a long way to contest this view.
The need to even discuss Biblical inerrancy is due to all of the false teachings and writings since the beginning of Christianity. In Acts the opposition began with the Sanhedrin, who had their power to lose with the message of Christ. People opposed the message when is cost them their income (demon possessed little girl fortuneteller, Demetrius the silver idol maker).
As the message spread people started making up their own beliefs. The Gnostic writings were started around 150 years after Christ and claimed that Jesus never existed in the flesh, just in spirit. These types of things are why there was a need to canonize the books of the Bible in the late 3rd and early 4th centuries. The only book that was roundly debated for canonization was Revelation. This had nothing to do with its Godly inspiration, just the fact that it was not widely used for spreading the message.
The early church’s disagreements centered on Jewish versus Gentile issues, like circumcision and other customs. There was not disagreement about the Gospel of Jesus Christ. The further away from the original believers the more manmade influence was interjected. That is what most of Paul’s writings are, correction to the truth.
While I would agree that 1st Century Christians were not running around with their bound Zondervan Bibles, they did have available, in relatively short order, the books and letters that make up our New Testament. These writings were considered to be the Word of God, written by inspired men chosen by God, mainly Paul and the Apostles.
Paul in writing to the church at Corinth said "For what I received I passed on to you as of first importance[a]: that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, 4that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures," The earliest known Creed was written sometime between A.D. 38-45, Paul is referencing it here.
The fact that Paul is referencing a known Creed indicates that even as early as 38 A.D. there was a written record of the events that occurred surrounding the birth, life, death and resurection of Jesus. AD I agree with Randy on this on. The 66 books/letters that make up the Bible today were in their original manuscripts, the original footprints the inspired, innerrant Word of God.
You both are thinking about the canonization of the Bible as what it means to refer to Biblical inerrancy. I am talking about the content not the decision about which books to include or not. If you want to include that in the definition, you will make your requirements even more daunting, since undoubtedly there were dozens of books that were debated for inclusion. (mid 4th century codex sinaiticus contained our 27 NT books but still had the letter of Barnabas and the Shepherd of Hermas included.)
I would categorize that as the discussion of orthodox teaching vs non-orthodox and not the inerrant word.
To include biblical inerrancy as a requirement simply does not make sense since there were some communities that probably and half the Bible we know today and dozens of books (then thought to be scripture) that we don’t. Consequently, you are suggesting that the pre Constantine Christians were incapable of achieving this knowledge of Biblical inherency and therefore fail the creed.
Do we really need such an optimistic appraisal of early church history in order to feel good about our beliefs? Keep in mind that our orthodox beliefs today were in the minority in the early movement. This is what should make you feel better not worse.
AD, I have struggled to respond. I have read your posts three times and I am still not sure I understand what you are getting at. Are we talking semantics or do you believe there are errors in the Bible?
When I talk Biblical inerrancy, I am saying that the books and letters of the Bible were written by men, who were inspired by God to write what He wanted said. The Word of God has been faithfully transcribed and translated over the centuries and today is still the Word of God, error free. Paul acknowledged this in 2 Timothy 3:16-17 when he wrote “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work”.
This also means that 1st century Christians would have been more than capable of understanding that the books and letters were the Word of God and were without error. If the books and letters of the Bible had never been canonized and turned into one complete set, we would be at the Christian Book store buying individual copies of them and compiling our own “Bible”. “I would like the Book of John and the three letter bonus pack, please”. Some people might buy a book of Thomas or a Gnostic book and be led astray, just like today with things like The DaVinci Code.
The current leadership of the Episcopal Church does not believe in Biblical inerrancy. This has led to challenges of Jesus’ divinity and Jesus being the only means to salvation (and created many other issues within the denomination). This does not mean that there are errors in the Bible. This means that there are errors in the leadership of the Episcopal Church.
I think the problem is we are working with different definitions at different time periods. To avoid further confusion, let us establish a time line for peoples and the Bible. I’ll use Athanasius (early 4th century) as the time frame for the composition of the Bible we know it today.
Before Athanaisus: It was only the Apostolic Fathers and the proto-orthodox community (mainly in Rome) that possessed correct doctrine about Christ. Still, none of these peoples could have given you an exact count of the books we know to make up the New Testament. Also, when you quote Paul, which scriptures do you think he was referring to? When Paul talks about the Gospel in his early texts, he certainly is not thinking Matthew, Mark, Luke or John. Now, I have no doubt that the proto orthodox Christians had a correct understanding of the true message and meaning of Christ. However at this time it did not come by way of an exclusive corpus of sacred writings.
If you want to introduce “Biblical Inerrancy “ here and postulate proto-orthodox Christians must maintain our exact listing of the New Testament as a requirement, then you eliminate all of them since no one had decide which books to be exclusive, otherwise the cannon would have already been established. That would be like writing someone a ticket now for a law that will be on the books two years from now.
After Athanasius: You can easily quote Paul referring to the scriptures since it is know that these 66 books are the exclusive account of the Godly inspired Holy Scriptures (it has been 2000 years already.)
If by “ Biblical Inerrancy” you mean that inclusion of other books claiming to occupy the same status ( the book of Mormon) as heretical, then I completely agree.
The cannon is closed. Even if Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians was discovered and somehow verified, I would still not include it in the Bible.
Now here is where the term Biblical Inerrancy gets tricky. I need a more extensive definition. Do you mean that only empirically verifiable events can be accepted as true or do you consider truth in meaning as inerrant? On a math test if the answer is 3000 and you calculate 2999, then your test has an error and is marked incorrect. Consequently, in scripture we are told at Pentecost that some 3000 converted that day. What if it were actually 2998, would the Bible be in error? Or, for that matter any other time numerical data is given in scripture. What about the historical actuality of events? Do they have to have occurred exactly as described in the Bible. When did Jesus cleanse the temple? What day was he crucified on? Do we look at the message the author is trying to communicate and consider that as truth, or do we employ the modern understanding of historical positivism and uphold the Bible as authentic data reporting to be considered authentic?
Applying the term inerrancy to scriptures in an attempt to validate it absolutely has only succeeded in dividing and confusing the body of Christ.
Judgmental overtones now abound. I don’t interpret Genesis as six literal 24 hour days, am I denying the inerrancy of the Bible? It is this aspect of Biblical Inerrancy that prompted my original post. (this can also be applied to the before Athanasius time period) I hope this clears up my position. A.D.
To me, inerrancy means to be without error. That does not always mean scripture is precise. Precision is not always necessary to convey meaning. If I were to write that my vehicle gets 26MPG on the freeway, but the actual calculation is 25.782MPG, that does not mean I have an error. My lack of precision still conveys the information you need.
The censuses in the book of Numbers always seem to be nice round numbers. Could these counts be precise? Yes. Do the counts have to be precise to be both true and without error? No. The exactness does not change the message conveyed.
The four Gospels all tell about Jesus’ time on earth. Two cover His birth, two do not. Some cover certain miracles, some cover others. One may touch on an event, another provide more information about that event. The inclusion of an event in one book does not make another book without that event to be in error. These are different books written for different audiences.
The 2 Timothy reference was for the ‘God breathed’ part. I agree that any reference to scripture in the New Testament is a reference to the Old Testament.
I can see that both of you are correct. AD this is no doubt that the Canon of Scripture was set centuries after the events took place. And Randy is equally correct in his assertion of the inerrancy of Scripture. There can be little or no doubt that the compilation of books and letters we possess today and that we know as the Bible are in fact God breathed in there orignal autographs. The fact that we have more copies of ancient manuscripts (not the original autographs)than of any other writing of antiquity indicates that God's purpose was that we would have an accurate (some estimates say 99% accurate)rendition of those orginal manuscripts. AD there can be little doubt of the accurancy of the canon and I agree that if a manuscript today was found of that real first letter Paul wrote to the church at Corinth it wouldn't be included in the canon not because a copy didn't survive but rather even if a copy of that manuscript had survived those chosen by God to set the Canon of Scripture soley on the basis of the criteria that they used, even of that meant casting lots.
I think we can come to an agreement that what we know is the Bible was inspired by God and that He used men moved by the Holy Spirit to pen the words that He that He wanted wanted to convey to subsequent generations.
There really is something to be said about the unchanged longevity of our Holy scriptures. Indeed, Paul could have written a hundred letters, yet providence dictates that the extant ones are to be transmitted as divinely ordained. I would agree with the term "inerrancy" as pertaining to God's will in the entirety and accuracy of the gospel message.
Post a Comment